Permitted Obstructions: What Can Go in a Required Yard in NYC
What is allowed in a required yard in NYC zoning?
Nothing may be built above ground in a required yard except the permitted obstructions the Zoning Resolution lists (ZR 23-313). Each comes with a cap: eaves 16 inches or 20 percent of the yard width, chimneys 3 feet, front-yard fences 4 feet, rear-yard sheds 10 feet tall, mechanical equipment 25 percent of the yard, and balconies 7 feet deep or one third of the yard (ZR 23-311, 23-312, 23-341, 23-62). Check your district and its yard rules free on Zohgo.
Yard depth is only half the question. The other half is what you are allowed to put in that yard, and the Zoning Resolution answers it with a precise list of permitted obstructions, each with its own size limit.
Yards are open space, with a fixed list of exceptions
Once a lot's front, side and rear yards are set, the Zoning Resolution says no building or other structure may be built above ground level in a required yard or rear yard equivalent unless it is a listed permitted obstruction (ZR 23-313). The list is layered. ZR 23-311 covers items allowed in every yard, court and required open area. ZR 23-312 adds items allowed in any yard or rear yard equivalent. ZR 23-341 adds more for rear yards and rear yard equivalents only. Courts have their own list in ZR 23-351, and commercial and manufacturing districts use ZR 33-23 and ZR 43-23, which pull in the residential lists and add their own.
Each item comes with a size cap, and the caps are where projects get caught. Below are the limits exactly as the current text states them, last amended December 5, 2024 with City of Yes for Housing Opportunity.
Allowed in every yard, court and open area (ZR 23-311)
- Accessory mechanical equipment limited to 18 inches in depth from an exterior wall.
- Awnings and sun control devices. Above the first story they may project at most 2 feet 6 inches from the wall, and their solid surfaces may cover no more than 30 percent of that wall in elevation.
- Chimneys projecting no more than 3 feet into the yard and covering no more than 2 percent of the required yard.
- Eaves, gutters and downspouts extending no more than 16 inches or 20 percent of the yard width, whichever is less.
- Window sills and similar projections, no more than 4 inches.
- Solar on walls existing on April 30, 2012: up to 10 inches deep and up to 20 percent of the wall surface. Solar above another permitted obstruction may add 18 inches of height.
- Also listed without a size cap: arbors and trellises, bicycle or micromobility parking, canopies, EV charging equipment, flagpoles, qualifying exterior wall thickness, ramps or lifts for people with disabilities, and open terraces or porches.
Added for any yard in residence districts (ZR 23-312)
- Unenclosed balconies, subject to ZR 23-62, but not in side yards and not within 5 feet of a side or rear lot line in a rear yard.
- Fences up to 4 feet above adjoining grade in a front yard. On a corner lot a fence may reach 6 feet in the part of one front yard between a side lot line and the extension of the side wall of the house.
- Overhangs on a single- or two-family house: portions above the first story may project up to 3 feet into the front yard, at least 7 feet above the yard, with supports covering no more than 15 percent of the area under the overhang.
- Energy infrastructure and accessory mechanical equipment (the category that covers items like outdoor AC condensers): screened per ZR 26-50, no more than 25 percent of a required yard and no more than 25 square feet in a front yard. Height cap in R1 to R5: 10 feet in rear and side yards, 5 feet in front yards. In R6 to R12: 15 feet.
- Open parking in side and rear yards. Front-yard parking is barred in R4B, R5B and R5D, and in other cases listed in ZR 23-312.
- Steps that reach only the lowest story or cellar of a building fronting on a street.
- Walls up to 8 feet, not roofed, and 4 feet in a front yard (6 feet on the same corner lot portion as fences).
Zohgo shows the zoning district, FAR, height and setbacks for any NYC address in about a minute. Free to start, sign in with Google or Apple.
Check any NYC address free on ZohgoAdded for rear yards and rear yard equivalents (ZR 23-341)
| Obstruction | Limit in the rear yard | Section |
|---|---|---|
| Shed, tool room or storage building | 10 ft above the yard level | ZR 23-341 |
| Accessory greenhouse | 1 story or 15 ft, whichever is less; 25% of the required rear yard | ZR 23-341 |
| Parking structure for a 1- or 2-family house | 10 ft high, detached from the house | ZR 23-341 |
| Parking structure for other residential buildings | 15 ft above base plane | ZR 23-341 |
| Solar on the roof of a permitted rear-yard structure | 4 ft; 18 in on a detached accessory structure or a roof sloped over 20 degrees | ZR 23-341 |
| Solar canopy over open parking | 15 ft above adjoining grade | ZR 23-341 |
| Breezeways, fire escapes, play and drying equipment | Listed, no size cap | ZR 23-341 |
| Unenclosed balcony | Per ZR 23-62 (see below) | ZR 23-341, 23-62 |
Rear yards can also take residential space in two specific cases: senior housing common space in R6 to R12 (not R6B, R7B or R8B) within 100 feet of a wide street, limited to one story or 15 feet, and portions of a single- or two-family home such as an ancillary dwelling unit, limited to one-third of the rear yard. The ADU rules are covered in our NYC ADU guide. One catch: a rear yard equivalent that is also a required front or side yard can only hold what that front or side yard allows (ZR 23-341).
Balconies: the ZR 23-62 limits
Balconies get their own section. Inside a required yard, court or open area a balcony may project no more than one third of the depth of that area or 7 feet, whichever is less, may cover no more than 10 percent of the required open area, and its aggregate width at any story may not exceed 50 percent of the wall it projects from. Railings top out at 4 feet 6 inches and parapets at 4 feet. The balcony must be at least 13 feet above curb level, except on residential buildings no taller than 35 feet, where it may start at the second floor but not below 7 feet (ZR 23-62).
Worked example: a 25 x 100 ft row house lot in R5B
Say the building leaves a 30 foot rear yard, the depth ZR 23-342 requires for an attached building on a lot narrower than 40 feet. The required rear yard is 25 x 30 = 750 square feet.
- AC condensers and other mechanical equipment: 25% x 750 = 187.5 square feet of footprint, up to 10 feet tall in R5B (ZR 23-312).
- Shed: allowed, up to 10 feet above the rear yard level (ZR 23-341).
- Greenhouse: up to 25% x 750 = 187.5 square feet, one story or 15 feet (ZR 23-341).
- Rear balcony at the third floor: one third of 30 feet is 10 feet, so the 7 foot cap governs. Its width is capped at 50% of a 25 foot rear wall, or 12.5 feet, and its area at 10% of 750, or 75 square feet. A 7 x 10.7 foot balcony uses all 75. It cannot sit within 5 feet of either side lot line (ZR 23-312, 23-62).
- Front yard: R5B requires a 5 foot front yard (ZR 23-321). A front fence or wall tops out at 4 feet, front-yard mechanical equipment at 25 square feet and 5 feet tall, and no parking space is allowed there at all in R5B (ZR 23-312).
Commercial and manufacturing districts
In C and M districts, ZR 33-23 and ZR 43-23 start from the residential lists in ZR 23-311 and ZR 23-341 and add their own. In any yard: fences, open accessory parking, steps, unroofed walls up to 8 feet, and mechanical or energy equipment up to 23 feet above curb level. In rear yards, the big one is a non-residential building of one story, up to 23 feet above curb level, plus accessory parking structures to 23 feet. In C7 districts and M districts with an A suffix that ground-floor obstruction may be two stories and 30 feet. Rooms for living or sleeping never count as an obstruction.
This page covers obstructions in yards. Required yard depths themselves, and the separate list of obstructions allowed above height and setback limits (ZR 23-41), are different rules. Special districts and landmarks can add limits. Check the current text before you file.
Permitted obstructions FAQ
Can I put an AC condenser in my rear yard?
Yes. Accessory mechanical and energy infrastructure equipment is a permitted obstruction in any yard if it is screened, covers no more than 25 percent of the required yard, and in R1 to R5 stays under 10 feet in rear and side yards (5 feet in front yards, where it is also capped at 25 square feet). In R6 to R12 the height cap is 15 feet (ZR 23-312).
How tall can a shed be in a rear yard?
A shed, tool room or similar storage structure in a required rear yard or rear yard equivalent may be up to 10 feet above the level of the rear yard (ZR 23-341).
How far can a balcony project into a yard?
No more than one third of the depth of the yard or 7 feet, whichever is less, covering no more than 10 percent of the required open area, with aggregate width no more than 50 percent of the wall it projects from. Balconies are not allowed in side yards or within 5 feet of a side or rear lot line in a rear yard (ZR 23-62, 23-312).
How high can a front yard fence be?
4 feet above adjoining grade. On a corner lot, a fence or wall may be up to 6 feet in the part of one front yard between a side lot line and the extension of the house's side wall (ZR 23-312).
Can eaves overhang the side yard?
Yes. Eaves, gutters and downspouts may extend into a yard up to 16 inches or 20 percent of the yard's width, whichever is less (ZR 23-311).
What can go in a rear yard in a commercial district?
Besides the residential lists, a non-residential building of one story and no more than 23 feet above curb level, accessory parking structures up to 23 feet, and equipment up to 23 feet. In C7 the ground-floor obstruction may be two stories and 30 feet (ZR 33-23).
Related pages
Sources
Residential yard obstruction sections were last amended December 5, 2024 (City of Yes for Housing Opportunity).
- ZR 23-311: Permitted obstructions in all yards, courts and open areas: https://zr.planning.nyc.gov/article-ii/chapter-3/23-311
- ZR 23-312: Additional permitted obstructions in all yards: https://zr.planning.nyc.gov/article-ii/chapter-3/23-312
- ZR 23-313: Level and measurement of yards: https://zr.planning.nyc.gov/article-ii/chapter-3/23-313
- ZR 23-341: Permitted obstructions in rear yards or rear yard equivalents: https://zr.planning.nyc.gov/article-ii/chapter-3/23-341
- ZR 23-351: Permitted obstructions in courts: https://zr.planning.nyc.gov/article-ii/chapter-3/23-351
- ZR 23-62: Permitted obstructions for balconies: https://zr.planning.nyc.gov/article-ii/chapter-3/23-62
- ZR 23-342: Rear yard requirements: https://zr.planning.nyc.gov/article-ii/chapter-3/23-342
- ZR 23-321: Front yards in R1 through R5: https://zr.planning.nyc.gov/article-ii/chapter-3/23-321
- ZR 33-23: Permitted obstructions, Commercial Districts: https://zr.planning.nyc.gov/article-iii/chapter-3/33-23
- ZR 43-23: Permitted obstructions, Manufacturing Districts: https://zr.planning.nyc.gov/article-iv/chapter-3/43-23